That means they do not qualify as the noun attack, but they still qualify as an action attacking on someone (verb) I am certain that Jeremy Crawford confirmed that the effects are not 'an attack'. It is using the word attack as a VERB, not a noun. Note it does not say 'take an attack action', or even 'make an attack'. You remain invisible until the ring is removed, until you attack or cast a spell, or until you use a bonus action to become visible again. In particular, read the ring of invisibilty AGAIN: You would not believe how many people think that you can not cast two leveled spells in the same round simply because they mis-read what Jeremy Crawford said about bonus actions. You may be misinterpreting his rule, so you need to actually QUOTE him. Part of the reason is that 9 times out of 10, people think he said something different than what he actually said. Quote him, showing where and exactly WHAT he said. Yeah, in general the mastermind is a good source, but not enough. Saying confirmed by Jeremy Crawford is not evidence. I would rule that making a saving throw IS an attack. So am I wrong for assuming that, if a party fights xanathar, they could face him while he is invisible and just shooting his eyebeams everywhere? They are also not considered "spells" because these are innate abilities. Similar to the fact that you can cast dragon's breath on a familiar and, even tho it isnt allowed to make an attack, it can use the dragons breath to force someone to make a saving throw. None of the beholder's eyestalk effects are technically "attacks" because it forces a saving throw and don't make an attack roll. You remain invisible until the ring is removed, until you attack or cast a spell, or until you use a bonus action to become visible again. Anything you are wearing or carrying is invisible with you. While wearing this ring, you can turn invisible as an action.
What I am wondering mainly is the combination of xanathar's eyestalk effects and the ring of invisibility. He basically is a normal beholder wearing a ring of mind shielding, ring of resistance (force) and a ring of invisibility.
I have been looking into Xanathar's stats. Monstrous Compendium Vol 3: Minecraft Creatures
0 kommentar(er)
